.It's deja vu across again for the Bulldogs, knocked straight out of the finals with Luke Beveridge's dubious moves in the spotlight.Plus Geelong's rebuild on the run, where the Heeney Robbery positions enduring, Brisbane's clear imperfection and also the much-needed primary award change.The big concerns coming from week among the 2024 AFL finals analysed in Speaking Points!Watch the most effective coverage of the 2024 AFL finals, with expert analysis and also every video game up until the Grand Final deal with no ad-breaks during the course of play, on Kayo. New to Kayo? Beginning your cost-free trial today > Finals Week 1IMAGINE WHAT YOU MIGHT BE PURCHASING INSTEAD. Completely free and also private help phone call 1800u00a0858u00a0858 or visit gamblinghelponline.org.au.The Week 1 finals AFL Chatting Aspects are in.Source: FOX SPORTSOOPS, BEVO DID IT AGAINNext year, the Western Bulldogs must only reach replicate, as well as bypass every little thing till the last round. Because they just always keep doing the very same things once again as well as again.For the third year in a row their finals destiny decreased to the final day for the fifth opportunity given that the 2016 banner, they located themselves in an eradication final.And the feast-or-famine nature of their Septembers continued as, for the 4th opportunity, they were actually knocked out of the finals without a win.But the deja vu doesn't quit there because once again the Bulldogs' time finishes with Luke Beveridge's decision-making arriving under fire.They were actually affordable early versus Hawthorn yet traits promptly collapsed on Friday night as well as you must think about how much of the loss came on Thursday night, when the decided on staff was actually shown. Since the tinkerer went to it again.Mitchell deals with Ginni's bar tricks|01:44 The positional problems started in defence, as they usually eat the Bulldogs over the last few years. Rory Lobb's rise into an amazingly good secret defender carried on however he merely failed to possess sufficient assistance Liam Jones limited Port Gunston but didn't carry out a lot in other places, while James O'Donnell was actually effectively defeated through Calsher Dear.The two are actually likewise unskilled therefore by itself that is actually certainly not a huge surprise but it's still pretty ludicrous that the 56th choice in the best latest nationwide receipt managed to dominate the Dogs aerially like he did.But it had not been simply the defence, considering that any sort of back 6 will possess battled when having to stand up for 59 inside 50s - the much bigger concern was actually the Pet dogs creating only 39 inside 50s of their own.Harvey Gallagher spent plenty of opportunity on an airfoil, rather than Lachie McNeil who proceeded, as well as neither man had an effect while Lachie Thorn summarized among the Bulldogs' significant checklist concerns - with the earlier delisted Hawk needed as one of their primary suppliers off halfback.Bramble simply isn't very powerful good enough in that duty the lack of prime Caleb Daniel, who has actually diminished sufficient defensively that he can't be actually downplayed back, has been actually notable.Throw in the baffling non-selection of Rhylee West, that would certainly possess likely made an effort to confine James Sicily in the Pet dogs' ahead fifty, along with James Harmes favored however doing little - and also the bits-and-pieces players only seemed to become in the incorrect places.High flighting Hawks knock out Bulldogs|02:26 And after that there's the Bont.Beveridge fired up in his post-match interview when the additions of probably the AFL's best player were examined." Have you got facts on that particular (his downtime the ground)? He might have acquired thrust on (the bench) for a minute or two longer (than intended), but he was OK," the trainer claimed." He attempted to raise us in the final one-fourth, he booted an objective, he almost kicked a 2nd (a try contacted by teammate Aaron Naughton near the line), which was the information at three-quarter opportunity." Whether he was lugging a trauma or otherwise, Marcus Bontempelli possessed nowhere near sufficient effect for the Bulldogs to possess a come across Friday evening, and the genuine inquiry is why he wasn't in the midfield by means of the middle of the game - especially if he was fit.Despite Beveridge's demonstrations, Bontempelli spent 22% of the 2nd and 3rd one-fourths incorporated off the ground, and also while on the ground possessed merely four disposals, no clearances and no rating engagements, investing practically the entire time period up forward.Once Bontempelli entered the center early in the fourth one-fourth, he seemed like themself once more. Yet it was inadequate, late." No impact in a ruthless final. The most effective player, the All-Australian leader, is either unemployed or even onward," as Kane Cornes put it on Nine's Sunday Footy Show.None of these positional telephone calls, on their own, are actually why the Bulldogs shed. The Hawks also played definitely damn properly, with their stress resulting in the Pet dogs' switch game to fall apart.But they all lead to a consistent fad of Beveridge dabbling his means to both excellence and also failing. He doesn't possess the greatest list in the AFL, like some experts point out, considering that the workers down back as well as probably partially of the midfield continue to be an issue.Dejected Bevo particulars what went wrong|09:39 Yet their finest is actually accurately acceptable. As always occurs with the Dogs, they played fantastic footy sometimes throughout the home and away season yet were actually not regular enough to earn the dual odds. (They have actually still never ended up in the leading four under Beveridge.) So when they faced a red-hot Hawthorn, one bad evening was enough to end their season. It is actually a bit of a shame, due to the fact that this staff was definitely sufficient over the rear fifty percent of the year to win multiple finals (and also perhaps even the large one), yet they fell small in their one opportunity - so they can merely condemn themselves.They are actually also excellent, and Beveridge has been actually as well productive over his job, to force an improvement on top. But they are practically trapped in this particular loophole of good-but-not-good-enough, as well as if it's greatly aggravating for onlookers, it needs to be also worse for the Bulldogs faithful.WHAT'S brand-new PUSSYCATS?Geelong's potential to continue to be on top of the AFL mountain range for so long is actually utterly remarkable.When you look at the absolute most effective staffs in recent times, Geelong's account is actually a lot more impressive.Hawthorn undeniably possessed a golden age in the very early 2010s, but success over the Bulldogs on Friday evening was their first finals gain in nine years.Richmond gained three flags in 4 seasons but now looked fated to stay in the blue funk of the AFL ladder for an amount of years with a mass gamer exodus looming.On the other hand, Geelong has lost out on September action merely twice in the past 18 seasons. That is amazing congruity in a competition that is actually actually made to try and make every effort towards equality.One of the significant elements responsible for their astonishing success previously two decades is their ability to find a diamond in the rough when it involves the draft.Scott opens up on variety wager|09:03 Geelong have actually gathered up two complete superstars coming from the receipt lately, in Lawson Humphries as well as Shaun Mannagh.Externally during in 2013's business period, inquiries were asked about why the Kitties were being therefore unfaltering in requesting an overdue pick back in gain in the Esava Ratugolea field. Why were they being so firm regarding obtaining one more pick back that they might certainly not even utilize come draft night?The Kitties decided on Humphries, a fairly not known Swan Districts item, with the second last selection of in 2014's draught-- choose 63. Humphries has actually starred in his handful of activities at the top level, showcasing brilliant calmness as well as round use around the half-back line.The 182cm kid is actually a wonderful decision-maker and has turned into one of Chris Scott's 'best individuals' visiting of support. On Thursday evening he was one of Geelong's finest, acquiring twenty disposals as well as 486 metres gained.Then there is actually Shaun Mannagh, the mature-aged VFL celebrity that has actually come to be a nail down the greatest 23 in the second one-half of the year. Mannagh placed his label up in lightings in the 2023 VFL marvelous last, where he booted six majors and scored 28 disposals. The 27-year-old was awarded with an AFL agreement in last year's draft, taken along with selection 36, and also hasn't he paid back the faith?Mannagh was among his side's finest versus the Power in the qualifying final, recording 23 disposals and 3.1. The past Werribee product places elite for disposals and also addresses this time and also has balanced 1.3 goals per activity as a medium-forward. Rising Superstar Ollie Dempsey has additionally come on in jumps as well as bounds this period to become one of the absolute most essential players to an edge willing to embark on yet another preparatory final.Not merely have the Cats had the capacity to find results at the draught, yet their distinct recruitment strategy has actually additionally viewed them become a place club for opposition players too.The Pet cats marketed the ranch for ex-Giant Jeremy Cameron as well as the lifestyle also interested currently captain Patrick Dangerfield. Include the similarity Port Bowes, Tanner Bruhn, Tyson Stengle as well as Oliver Henry, the Pet cats have possessed no troubles marketing themselves as a home for place players.But it is actually not as though the Cats have not changed. 9 players that featured in Thursday evening's training final victory carried out not play in the 2022 premiership, simply two years ago.ABC's Kyle Pollard mentioned on X that that is certainly not dissimilar to Richmond at this moment." For situation, Richmond's final round group this year possessed 11 that didn't play in their premierships," he mentioned." That is actually not a take on the Tigers, it is actually just an awesome 24 months of rejuvenation coming from Geelong." While Chris Scott as well as the on-field superstars get a lot of distinctions and appropriately therefore, the work of Stephen Wells, Andrew Mackie and the recruiting team is actually second to none in this particular competition.Geelong dominate bad Slot Adelaide|03:02 HEENEY PARTICIPATES IN THE SCG'S REMARKABLE MOUNT RUSHMOREIt might not be actually the home of footy, however the SCG is actually the home of enduring finals moments.Sydney's Isaac Heeney-led comeback on Saturday afternoon participates in the pantheon of unbelievable September activity to have actually happened at the renowned venue.Former Footscray and Sydney player turned writer Neil Cordy quipped it would be called 'Heeney's Heist' after the celebrity's 30-disposal, three-goal game.But the fourth finals edition of the Sydney Derby might certainly not have even been the greatest comeback by the Swans in an SCG final.Swans COMEBACK coming from 27-point deficiency|03:29 Nevertheless the 2005 flag wouldn't have been actually achievable if Scar Davis had not had an other-worldly fourth quarter in the semi-final, kicking four of Sydney's 7 targets on the night in the room of 21 minutes to stun Geelong.Don' t forget the 1996 preliminary ultimate, when any score would create for Tony Lockett, as well as Plugger's factor placed the Swans in to the flag decider.And heck, Saturday's certifying ultimate could certainly not have actually been the greatest ultimate at the SCG this years! Don't forget Collingwood's near-comeback in the 2022 prelim, when the Swans led through six targets early in the 3rd one-fourth, and also through 21 factors with 22 mins used the fourth?The risks were actually high in every 4 games yet the nature of Sydney's comeback on Saturday, versus their arch-rivals and also along with some unreasonable private attempts, could create it No. 1. As well as the very best part? It suggests we are actually getting an additional game at the SCG in pair of full weeks' opportunity, when the Swans lot either Slot Adelaide or even Hawthorn in a prelim.Swans-Port is actually fascinating after the technique the Electrical power destroyed them a couple of weeks back Swans-Hawks is actually also a lot better, provided exactly how far Sam Mitchell's males have come given that being actually bashed through John Longmire's edge to be up to 1-6 on the season.Let's just hope it is actually another close one." ULTIMATE RIDE" Heeney Hanger stops SCG|00:30' FRETTING INDICATORS' COUGARS NEEDED TO HAVE TO ADDRESSBrisbane may have placed Carlton to the sword with a 1st one-half demolition on Saturday evening, but Fox Footy's professionals fear there is actually still issues for train Chris Fagan.Despite a sensational beginning where the Lions dove out to a 60-0 lead, resigning Carlton to a 50-year footy low, Brisbane then went greater than 30 minutes without a goal.And they dealt with to butcher a lot of chances when the heat energy originated from a rising Woe outfit." Brisbane, I reckon there's some distressing signs certainly there for Chris Fagan," three-time premiership Tiger Port Riewoldt claimed." They must have abused Carlton tonight. They should possess placed that nail in the coffin early in the second one-half." Regrettably, they allow all of them back in. They didn't win tough." The video game mored than after part opportunity." AFL wonderful Garry Lyon acknowledged, highlighting the simple fact they won through merely 28 aspects - in spite of the early 60-0 scoreline.From that point in the 2nd term, Brisbane were actually outscored 71-39. Lions Strike Blues in Elimination Final|02:39" 2nd half has been an issue through the course of the year. A little of breakdown," Lyon said.Lions fantastic Jonathan Brown claimed he fears the concern is actually psychological for the young Cougars, as inaccuracy and also a failure to preserve their first half stress remains to reach." I really feel as if it's certainly not an exercise point, not an energy trait. I believe it's a bit of a mental turn off," he said." It remains in their head." They kicked properly very early in the activity (against Carlton), however after half time they were actually usual." I presume when resistance receives an operate on, there is actually a feeling of panic. Some anxiety in there. There is actually some marks, no doubt regarding that." They have not had the ability to manage the stress in those vital instants with those crucial kicks-- that's mosting likely to be actually the obstacle following full week." They miss out on a great deal of very easy tries." I've seen all of them carefully all year-- I am actually a passionate Brisbane Lions proponent. They miss out on simple chance ats objective. Establish chances or even on the operate." Against the Blues, Logan Morris went to the post coming from directly ahead while the edge butchered an additional chance when they possessed an overlap inside 50 as well as neglected to reach a target.Riewoldt defined the reliability concerns due to "reverse pressure". They place 15th in the AFL for reliability this year, in advance of only West Coast, Richmond as well as Port Adelaide.In their final 4 matches, Brisbane have actually gone 44.64 on the scoreboard, along with goalkicking costing all of them a top-four location when they shed 8.16 to GWS' 13.4 in Sphere 22. They likewise dropped winnable games against Carlton in Opening Around (12.13 to 13.8), Collingwood in Around 3 (10.12 to 14.8) and also Geelong in Sphere 6 (4.13 to 9.9) as a result of their inaccuracy." What have our experts reached lose?"|04:23' WE'VE GOT TO IMPROVEMENT THAT GUIDELINE': IS AFL HONOR phone call UNFAIR?Players and experts claim it's opportunity for the AFL to listen closely to the enthusiasts and also change the qualification criteria bordering the Score and also Goal of the Year awards.First it was actually Jeremy Cameron's enchanting finish, put near to the border product line on Thursday night, as he got the Felines off to a goal beginning at the Adelaide Oval. On Sunday night it was actually Swans superstar Isaac Heeney, who levitated to take some of the all-time excellent grabs. The worst component-- neither will be entitled for the reputable awards.As it stands, merely minutes in the home as well as away season are actually taken into account for the awards, which exist on Brownlow Award night before the huge final. But in the wake of observing 2 of the time's very most distinctive moments, there's been plenty of ask for the AFL to alter its rules. "Our company have actually reached alter that policy, Jeremy Cameron kicked goal of the year in finals and after that Isaac Heeney's taken score of the year," Swans small onward Tom Papley informed 3AW post-match. Jezza opens finals set with astonishment!|00:35 Network 9's Damian Barrett also participated in the chorus of pros asking for change, saying he felt Heeney's wall mount was the most effective score of the year. "That to me is actually mark of the year yet unfortunately it will not be actually consisted of in the factors to consider," he lamented on the Sunday Footy Show.Former Leopard and also Bulldog Nathan Brown resided in agreeance." I believe it needs to be, you return to 1997, Aussie Jones stopped the objective of the year in the splendid last, people claim the other groups don't get an odds, I indicate there is actually a couple of opportunities," he said.Jones stopped an amazing operating goal in the '97 splendid last, while former Roo Aaron Edwards took a large mark against Hawthorn in the 2007 semi-final that has been actually "lost in past history" provided its ineligibility for the award.Former AFL gamer Josh Jenkins was actually also amongst those that spoke up concerning their contempt, taking to X to claim: "Objective of the year right certainly there ... wait they have actually finalized nominations." As a volleyball frat, gamers who stand on the most significant stage of all are actually commended and discover their spot in footy legend, therefore why are actually the Mark of the Year as well as Objective of the Year honors unaware of that?When you take into consideration the very best players to conform, those who have actually sampled success in September are actually constantly one of the very first players that involve mind.Think Michael Voss, Luke Hodge and also Joel Selwood. Premiership leaders that are actually held in the highest regard by all. Gamers are determined by their performances in finals." Leo Barry you star" was actually ingrained in past history when the Swans gun drifted throughout the pack to use that famous mark. Richmond captain Trent Cotchin's legacy was actually glued when he took his side back to the paradise. There's no promise that Heeney's hanger would outshine Jamie Elliott's ANZAC Time unique, or even that Cameron's outrageous surface would appropriate that of Scar Daicos or Harley Reid's targets, but they must at least be actually challengers.